| 1895/96 |
North of Scotland Cup Runners-Up |
| 1898/99 |
North of Scotland Cup Winners |
| 1909/10 |
Highland League Runners-Up |
| 1913/14 |
North of Scotland Cup Runners-Up |
| 1922/23 |
Highland League Runners-Up |
| 1923/24 |
North of Scotland Cup Winners |
| 1929/30 |
Highland League Runners-Up, North of Scotland Cup Runners-Up |
| 1931/32 |
Highland League Champions |
| 1932/33 |
Highland League Runners-Up |
| 1934/35 |
Highland League Champions |
| 1935/36 |
Scottish Qualifying Cup Winners |
| 1936/37 |
North of Scotland Cup Winners |
| 1939/38 |
Scottish Qualifying Cup Winners |
| 1946/47 |
Highland League Cup Runners-Up |
| 1947/38 |
North of Scotland Cup Runners-Up |
| 1948/49 |
Highland League Cup Runners-Up, Scottish Qualifying Cup Runners-Up, North of Scotland Cup Runners-Up |
| 1952/53 |
Highland League Champions |
| 1953/54 |
Highland League Runners-Up |
| 1954/55 |
North of Scotland Cup Winners |
| 1955/56 |
Highland League Champions, North of Scotland Cup Winners |
| 1957/58 |
Highland League Runners-Up |
| 1959/60 |
Highland League Champions, Highland League Cup Winners, Scottish Qualifying Cup Winners, North of Scotland Cup Runners-Up |
| 1960/61 |
Highland League Champions, North of Scotland Cup Winners |
| 1961/62 |
Highland League Runners-Up, North of Scotland Cup Winners |
| 1962/63 |
Highland League Champions |
| 1964/65 |
Highland League Champions, Scottish Qualifying Cup Winners |
| 1965/66 |
Highland League Champions, Highland League Cup Runners-Up |
| 1966/67 |
Highland League Runners-Up, Highland League Cup Winners, Scottish Qualifying Cup Runners-up |
| 1967/68 |
Highland League Champions, Scottish Qualifying Cup Winners, North of Scotland Cup Winners |
| 1968/69 |
Highland League Champions, North of Scotland Cup Winners |
| 1969/70 |
Highland League Champions, North of Scotland Cup Runners-Up |
| 1970/71 |
Scottish Qualifying Cup Winners, North of Scotland Cup Winners |
| 1971/72 |
Highland League Runners-Up, Scottish Qualifying Cup Runners-Up |
| 1972/73 |
North of Scotland Cup Winners |
| 1975/74 |
Highland League Champions |
| 1974/75 |
North of Scotland Cup Runners-Up |
| 1975/76 |
Scottish Qualifying Cup Runners-Up, North of Scotland Cup Winners |
| 1976/77 |
Scottish Qualifying Cup Runners-Up |
| 1979/80 |
North of Scotland Cup Runners-Up |
| 1981/82 |
Scottish Qualifying Cup Runners-Up |
| 1982/83 |
Highland League Runners-Up, Highland League Cup Winners, North of Scotland Cup Winners |
| 1983/84 |
Scottish Qualifying Cup Runners-Up |
| 1985/86 |
Highland League Runners-Up, Highland League Cup Runners-Up |
| 1988/89 |
North of Scotland Cup Winners |
| 1989/90 |
Highland League Champions, Scottish Qualifying Cup Winners, North of Scotland Cup Winners |
| 1990/91 |
Highland League Cup Winners |
| 1996/97 |
Scottish Qualifying Cup Runners-Up |
| 1997/98 |
Highland League Cup Winners, North of Scotland Cup Winners |
| 1998/99 |
North of Scotland Cup Winners |
| 1999/00 |
Highland League Cup Runners-Up |
| 2003/04 |
North of Scotland Cup Winners |
